One interesting trademark dispute from Japan shows us how difficult sometimes is famous trademarks to be invoked in opposition procedures.
The case concerns a trademark MACLOGIC filed by a local company in Japan for classes 9 and 42 – mainly computer software and design.
Against this mark, an opposition was filed by Apple Inc based on an earlier mark from MAC accompanied by a claim of trademark reputation. According to Apple, the mark applied for was similar to the earlier one due to the identical first part MAC, which was famous amongst Japanese consumers in relation to the company’s laptops and software. This was able to create consumer confusion in regard to the source of trade origin of the goods and services.
The Japan Patent Office, however, didn’t find both marks similar enough from a phonetic, visual, and conceptual point of view.
What’s a more, the Office considered the earlier mark reputation as established only for some consumers in the country but not for the public in general. Because of this, the opposition was dismissed.
The interesting moment in this decision was the fact that the reputation of a mark amongst the relevant consumers was not enough in order for this claim to be well established for the proceeding.